The Phillies never got it figured out in 2012, losing their final game yesterday in fitting fashion as the Nats topped them 5-1. Lee made a quality start and took the loss. The pen gave up a pair of runs in the eighth inning and Utley, Howard and Rollins combined to go 0-for-4 in the game with Rollins and Howard sidelined with injuries.
They end 2012 having won 21 fewer regular season games than they won in 2011.
Jimmy Rollins seems unfazed, coming up with this gem after the game that suggests the Nats would have finished second had the Phils been healthy: “It’s all come together for them. So that’s great for them. But with us being healthy, you know, they’re still second place. But we weren’t [healthy].”
Huh?
I’m having a lot of trouble understanding how the Phillies being healthy would have helped the Braves finish ahead of the Nationals.
I’m not even sure that’s what he meant.
Just so we’re all on the same page: The Phillies played baseball for about three hours on 162 different occasions in 2012. That’s a lot of baseball. It showed that they weren’t especially good relative to the teams they were playing against.
They weren’t especially good at scoring runs or preventing them.
They finished 17 games behind the best team in their division.
They paid Halladay, Howard, Utley and Rollins about $66 million to hit a combined 245/324/427 and throw to a 4.49 ERA over 25 starts.
Most fans would agree they have one young impact player in the organization, at least in terms of hitters. He hit .235 for the year and finished the season with numbers very similar to his disappointing 2011 season.
There are some problems here. The expensive core is getting old and looking older than they are. The Phils have close to no chance or replacing them or coming close to replacing them with players currently in the organization. Getting healthy would help, but if you think that’s the only thing the Phillies need, I think you might want to look again.
The Phillies have finished the 2012 season at 81-81, losing 5-1 to the Washington Nationals in yesterday’s final game of the year. The Phils end the year in third place, 17 games out of first and seven games out for the Wild Card. The Nats take the series two games to one.
Lee got the start for the Phillies and went six innings, allowing three runs on eight hits. Six of the hits went for extra-bases — three doubles, a triple and two home runs.
He set the Nationals down in order in the bottom of the first. Pierre made a fantastic play for the second out on a ball hit by Mark DeRosa, reaching up and over the fence to take away a home run.
Michael Morse doubled to left to start the second, but Lee set the Nats down in order behind him to leave Morse at second.
Jayson Werth tripled to center with two outs in the third. Lee got DeRosa on a fly ball to center to leave Werth stranded.
He started the fourth up 1-0. Ryan Zimmerman led off and hit a 1-2 pitch out to right. 1-1. Morse and Tyler Moore doubled back-to-back. 2-1 with nobody out and Moore at second. Lee got Ian Desmond on a foul out to Ruiz for the first out, then struck out Danny Espinosa and Jesus Flores back-to-back to leave Moore stranded.
Ugly start to the frame as the Nats go home run, double, double with their first three hitters.
Through four innings, Lee had allowed three doubles, a triple and a home run and given up just two runs.
Werth singled with one out in the fifth, but Lee got DeRosa and Zimmerman behind him.
Lee struck Morse out to start the sixth before Moore homered 3-2, extending the Washington lead to 3-1. Desmond followed with a single, but Lee struck Espinosa and Flores out back-to-back behind him at first.
De Fratus threw a 1-2-3 seventh. Switch-hitter Steve Lombardozzi hit for pitcher Christian Garcia and flew to right for the first out. Werth popped to third for the second and DeRosa grounded to second for the third.
Three up, three down for De Fratus. He allows five runs on the year over 10 2/3 innings in 13 appearances. Three of the five runs he allowed came in a single outing. He ends the year with a 3.38 ERA and a 1.12 ratio. Righties hit just 130/231/130 against him in 26 plate appearances.
Papelbon started the eighth. Zimmerman led off and walked. Bryce Harper ran for him at first. Morse was next and Papelbon got ahead of him 0-2 before Morse fouled off five pitches, then hit a 1-2 offering out to right-center for a two-run homer. 5-1. Papelbon struck Moore out swinging for the first out and righty Tyson Brummett came on to face Desmond. Desmond singled to left and moved up to second when Espinosa singled to right. It put men on first and second with one out for Flores. Brummett struck him out swinging for the second out. Lefty Chad Tracy hit for the pitcher Sean Burnett and Brummett struck him out swinging 2-2 to end the frame.
Papelbon faces three hitters and they go walk, homer strikeout. He was fantastic this year, ending with a 2.44 ERA and a 1.06 ratio. He came into yesterday’s appearance with an 0.59 ERA and an 0.88 ratio in 30 2/3 innings over his last 31 appearances.
28-year-old Tyson Brummett faces four batters in his debut, allowing singles to the first two before registering back-to-back strikeouts to leave the runners stranded.
Overall the pen goes two innings in the game, allowing two runs on three hits and a walk while striking out three.
Everyone should be well-rested of their next appearance.
The Phillies lineup against righty Edwin Jackson went (1) Pierre (2) Frandsen (3) Utley (4) Ruiz (5) Brown (6) Ruf (7) Schierholtz (8) Martinez. Mayberry on the bench with Schierholtz in center. Pierre plays left with Ruf at first for the sidelined Howard. Martinez starts at short for the sidelined Rollins.
The Phillies went in order in the top of the first.
Ruf walked with two outs in the second and moved to third on a ground-rule double down the left field line by Schierholtz. Martinez grounded to short to leave the runners at second and third.
Frandsen singled with two outs in the third. Utley grounded to second to set the Phillies down.
Ruiz started the fourth with a double and moved up to third when Brown grounded out for the first out. Ruf was next and he flew to center, deep enough for Ruiz to tag and score, putting the Phillies up 1-0. Schierholtz singled to center before Martinez flew to left to end the frame.
The Phillies were down 2-1 when they hit in the fifth. Lee and Pierre struck out back-to-back to start the inning before Frandsen doubled to left. Utley was next and hit the ball well, but Moore handled the line drive at first to leave Frandsen stranded.
Jackson set Ruiz, Brown and Ruf down in order in the sixth.
Schierholtz lined a double to right, his second double of the day, to start the seventh. Martinez flew to left for the first out. Nix hit for Lee and struck out swinging for the second. Righty Christian Garcia came in to face Pierre and got Pierre on a fly ball to center to leave Schierholtz stranded.
Lefty Sean Burnett set the Phillies down in order in the eighth.
Lefty Gio Gonzalez pitched the ninth with Washington up 5-1. Brown fouled out to third for the first out. Ruf struck out swinging 1-2 for the second out. Wigginton hit for Schierholtz and drew a walk. Martinez flew to left and the season was over.
Pierre was 0-for-4 and struck out twice yesterday in his only action of the series. Made a great catch in the first to take a homer away from DeRosa. He finishes the year at 307/351/371.
Frandsen 2-for-4 with a double. 6-for-13 with three doubles in the series. 338/383/451 in 210 plate appearances for the season.
Utley 0-for-4. 0-for-11 with a walk in the series. 256/365/429 for the year. Hit 215/324/355.
Ruiz 1-for-4 with a double. 1-for-8 with a double and a walk in the series. He was hitting 353/413/596 for the year at the end of the day on July 16. 250/345/390 in 116 plate appearances after July 16. Still ends the year at 325/394/540, which is the best year of his career with the bat by a wide margin.
Brown 0-for-4 in the game and 3-for-12 with a double in the series. He plans to have an MRI on his right knee today — let’s hope it reveals 120 ground outs to second that can be removed with a simple and safe surgical procedure. Ends the year at 235/316/396. 196/288/333 against lefties for the season.
Ruf 0-for-2 with a walk and two strikeouts. 3-for-8 with two walks, a triple, two home runs and five RBI in the three-game set. He also struck out five times. 333/351/727 for the year in 37 plate appearances.
Schierholtz 3-for-3 with two doubles. He finishes at 257/321/407 for the year. 273/319/379 with the Phillies in 73 plate appearances. He came into the game hitting 238/290/317 for the year with the Phillies over 70 plate appearances.
Martinez 0-for-4 and left five men on base. 2-for-11 with a strikeout in the series. 174/208/252 for the year.
No game today.
Stadium Journey recently published a new review of Citizens Bank Park.


October 4th, 2012 on 10:39 am
I’ve been in a coma for the past six months. Are you sure there is no game today? I was sure the Phillies would make the playoffs.
October 4th, 2012 on 10:49 am
Welcome back. Yep, just missed the playoffs. Was nip and tuck the whole way. Couple of bounces had gone the other way it would have been a whole different season.
October 4th, 2012 on 11:15 am
You’re explanation is much better than the truth.
Will be an interesting off-season for the team. Still hoping for two big bats and some starting pitching depth to be added to the team. Perhaps Rosenberg is the depth? Not really sure.
October 4th, 2012 on 11:16 am
And Brummett. Don’t forget Brummett.
October 4th, 2012 on 11:31 am
Two big bats a must, doncha think? Right handed, both of ‘em. And I could stand to see Vic back in addition if he has a reasonable cost/years demand.
What do y’all think about Madsen returning?
October 4th, 2012 on 11:35 am
Would love to have Madsen back, but that bridge seemed to be burned last year. Also thinking he’ll go someplace where he can close and re-establish his value. Houston maybe?
Vic seems done to me. Don’t really know what happened, but this year was bad. Would rather they spend a bit more and get Upton.
October 4th, 2012 on 11:37 am
I think one good bat plus role players might be enough, depending on the role players and what happens with the pitching.
Somebody needs to explain what happened with Halladay this year. The difference between the real Halladay and the guy we got this year is really, really big. If he’s going to bounce back, the rotation is pretty solid without a significant addition. If not, it’s not.
I would be happy to have Madson. I’d guess it’s not likely. I think he’ll still want a chance to close and there’s no chance for anyone but Papelbon to close for the Phils in ’13 if Papelbon is not hurt.
October 4th, 2012 on 11:48 am
I agree on Madson will go elsewhere. Victorino back wouldn’t excite me much. Upton joining the team definitely would.
I think it would take more than a little more than what it would take to get Victorino to get Upton. Big problem in CF that you can’t solve with Upton, though. Upton in right, Brown/Ruf in left and a real center fielder would be nifty, though. That’s a little more than we should be hoping for.
October 4th, 2012 on 12:30 pm
Interesting coaching moves. I thought Sandberg would be the bench coach. 3B coach is fine too.
Am I missing something, or did Ruf get something like the last 7 RBIs for the team for the year?
Agree with Vic being done. I like Bourn. Would really like the Phils to fill CF with a real leadoff guy and let JRoll hit 2nd or 3rd or 6th or something.
3B is going to be a problem. The only free agent worth getting is Wright. Barring some sort of trade, I bet you see Frandsen or Galvis or Fontenot starting at third next year. That wouldn’t be a problem as long as Ruf & Brown make one starting outfielder, with like Bourn and Upton or Hamilton making the other two. I thinking it’s more likely that Ruf & Brown will equal two starters. That’s a lot of dice rolling for an aging starting rotation.
October 4th, 2012 on 12:35 pm
Is one bat going to be enough, given that we presently have only four everyday starters on this team? Don’t we need at least two more so we actually have quality players agin?
I continue to look for some shred of evidence that Dom Brown belongs on a good baseball team. I just do not see it.
October 4th, 2012 on 12:40 pm
And I have to admit that if Brown is one of the starters, and if Ruf is another starter, then I do not see how this team will get to the post season.
October 4th, 2012 on 12:42 pm
Let me put together a starting lineup. Tell me if it instills confidence. (Note that Fontenot is actually a free agent; he could get a starting 2B spot with someone like the Astros so I’m not counting on him anymore.)
1. Bourn – CF
2. Frandsen – 3B
3. Utley – 2B
4. Howard – 1B
5. Ruf – LF
6. Ruiz – C
7. Rollins – SS
8. Brown – RF
I will say I feel better putting Brown out there every day than I do Mayberry.
October 4th, 2012 on 1:18 pm
That lineup does not install confidence. Frandsen can’t be the everyday 3B. Ruf can’t be the every day LF and he definitely can’t hit fifth. Bourn isn’t on the team.
Not sure if the Phils will face a lefty or a righty on Opening Day next year, but if Ruf and Brown are both in the lineup, it’s a bad sign. Don’t mind Brown against a lefty, but Ruf against a righty would worry me.
Ruf drove in all five of the runs the Phillies scored over their last three games, but none of the runs in the last game with the Fish.
Domonic Brown turned 25-years-old last month and has a career line of 296/373/461 in the minors, which is why people think he can be a good major leaguer.
October 4th, 2012 on 1:21 pm
Eric…I was thinking of BJ Upton, the free agent CF of the Rays, not his brother Justin, the RF for the Diamondbacks who may or may not be available via trade. Would be interesting if they trade for Justin and sign BJ.
That lineup does little to inspire confidence. I don’t know what it is about Bourn, but I’m just not a fan. Especially when I consider this teams offensive needs and what he provides. Rollins batting 7th will never happen, at least not next year.
If they do sign Bourn and he was the only off-season addition, I would think it would look more like:
Bourn
Utley
Rollins
Howard
Ruiz
Ruf/Brown
Nix/Mayberry
Frandsen
October 4th, 2012 on 1:27 pm
I suppose that it depends on what we want to be the result for next year. If we want to go to the Series, then to me that lineup doesn’t seem to get us there. And I assume that given the amount of money we have in pitching and so called core players that we are aiming for the Series.
Are Brown, Ruf, Frandsen good enough? I’d way rather a right handed power bat instead of Bourne and let Jimmy hit lead off.
October 4th, 2012 on 1:43 pm
I think it would be a massive mistake to make a $173 (or whatever) million bet that Fradsen, Ruf and Brown are enough (especially Frandsen and Ruf). Or Galvis, for that matter.
Sorry on the Upton mixup. Got Justin on my mind cause of the recent news of the likelihood of a trade. Less excited about BJ, but he does play center.
I do think they need one OF who can hit and they are likely to get that at a corner.
I think if Pierre and Schierholtz are both around when 2013 starts, that’s a really bad sign. Pierre honestly might be my favorite Phillie for this year and I hope he never plays a game with them again.
Brown is still very young. He just had his age 24 season. Through his age 24 season, Ryan Howard has 42 career plate appearances. Utley was hitting 239/322/373. Rollins was hitting 262/317/395. Ruiz was in the minors and would be for two more years before debuting in his age 27 season. So Brown’s got a ways to go, despite his ugly 230/315/396 line for his career so far.
October 4th, 2012 on 2:01 pm
I think having both Schierholtz and Nix under contract for 2013 makes it unlikely that Pierre will be back. Pierre adds an interesting element to the team (speed) but unless the Phillies eat the contract of one or both of those players, I just don’t see him being around.
I get confused on the Upton brothers all the time. But, in my dreamworld, the Phillies somehow work a trade for Justin to be the power hitter and BJ to be the above average hitter who plays great defense. As part of this dream, being on the same team inspires them to finally both reach their massive potential and gives the team some youth. Continuing in the dream, Brown becomes comfortable with his new swing and plays well enough to man LF every day.
Ruf stays on the team as a backup OF/1B and Howard is given a number of days off. Utley starts the season with the team and is able to play all year. Rollins stays healthy and Ruiz puts up numbers that are worse than 2012, but not dramatically so. Kratz proves to be a capable backup. Galvis comes back healthy and becomes the backup infielder that can’t hit when Martinez is finally let go. Nix is the LH bat off of the bench. Frandsen or somebody similar is signed to play third and bat 8th. Mayberry is a throw-in in the trade that brings Upton, and Schierholtz is traded for a bullpen arm.
October 4th, 2012 on 2:13 pm
Both Uptons would be pretty fun. That’s a lot of money, though. Kinda tough for me to imagine how it might work for the Phillies unless they trade away a huge contract.
Nix’s contract is pretty small — $1.35 for next year. I wouldn’t be stunned to see him not on the team for 2013. Schierholtz arbitration eligible and the Phils had Pierre on a minor league contract this year.
Also, 2013 is the last year guaranteed for Halladay. $20 million option for 2014.
The Phillies have to pay Lee $25 million a year in ’13, ’14 and ’15 before they have a $12.5 million buyout in ’16.
October 4th, 2012 on 3:06 pm
It’s a dream scenario where money doesn’t really matter. It isn’t mine, you know.
October 4th, 2012 on 3:22 pm
It seems like Lee might be someone they could trade if they really wanted to make salary room among the huge contract guys. He makes a lot of money and pitched well last year. Halladay makes a lot of money and didn’t pitch well. Hamels pitched well but doesn’t make Lee money. I assume Utley and Howard are pretty much undealable.
October 4th, 2012 on 3:23 pm
Schierholz, Nix, and Mayberry are too many 4th outfielders with no upside. Pierre doesn’t help the matter. The Phils have to acquire a major league CF from somewhere. I think Gillies will be in the MLB spring training, but not start the year on the 25-man.
If we’re being fair to Ruf, we should let him have a AAA season. Or at least start one. But then the only outfielder under contract that I would consider putting out there every day is Brown. I think we saw some positive flashes in 2012, and 2013 could be the breakout year. But that’s far from a sure thing, and it’s the best we’ve got. Need to find some outfielders, pronto.
October 4th, 2012 on 3:48 pm
I agree. I could see starting 2013 with Ruf as the right-handed part of a platoon. I think it would be a mistake to count on him for that, especially assuming there will be some big offensive question marks elsewhere (Brown, Frandsen or, dare I say, Galvis).
October 4th, 2012 on 4:19 pm
On money. Doncha think that having all these big contracts on present players at the ages they are means that they simply have to bite the bullet and get the players they need to get this team to the Series next year? Not the year after, but next year? I know that means they go over the cap, but they wasted a heck of a lot of salary money this year with false economy. are they really so dumb as to do it again?
Question. Howcome you don’t see Pierre next year.
Brown? I know I am in the minority, but I just do not see it. I watch him play. Doesn’t a greast prospect look like the kids in DC, Texas, and or California?
October 5th, 2012 on 8:37 am
I get the feeling that they will bite the bullet this year. The salary cap (or whatever they call it) goes up next year and they have 2-3 big contracts coming off of the books, so even if they go over somewhat this year they should be back under next year. The HUGE penalties come in for going over in consecutive years.
October 5th, 2012 on 9:08 am
If you’re trying to guess whether Brown will or won’t be a superstar, you’re definitely a lot better off guessing he won’t. There’s a chance, though. And a better chance that he will be an above average regular player.
It might take a few years.
I think they have three choices on the payroll — bite the bullet, trade away a huge contract or two or lose. Hopefully they stay away from lose.
October 5th, 2012 on 9:50 am
I’ll put it this way.. putting Brown out there every day is better, and more likely, than finding THREE new starting outfielders. He’s really the only one with potential upside who’s already played in AAA.
October 5th, 2012 on 1:52 pm
You’re probably right Jim. But boy do I hope there are at least two significant OF acquisitions next year, a corner and center. AND a third base pick up. At least two of them (hopefully all three) will be right handed bats. I’d sure like to see us face more righties next year than we have seen in what seems like forever. I bet our three and four hole guys would as well.
October 5th, 2012 on 1:54 pm
oh, yeah. Eric… why don’t you want Pierre back next year?? Too much money?
October 5th, 2012 on 2:08 pm
Cause the Phillies might give him 439 plate appearances again.
He’s a bad defensive player and can’t hit enough singles to make up his lack of power, at least as a corner OF. Basically, playing him in left prevents you from playing someone good in left.
And I love the guy.
He did have a good year last year, coming off of two years he was pretty bad. I would guess he’ll be worse wherever he plays in 2013.
October 5th, 2012 on 3:27 pm
In Pierre’s defense, there were only five players on the team with a better WAR for the season than him (Ruiz, Utley, Rollins, Hamels and Lee). A lot of that has to do with how much he got to play, but he definitely had his best season since 2009.
The WAR thing might say a little more about the Phillies than about Pierre. In 2011, the Phils ended the year with 11 players (five hitters and six pitches) with a WAR of 2.0 or higher. If you’re feeling nostalgic, Victorino led the hitters at 5.2 and the Phillies had three pitchers with a WAR better than six (and two with a WAR better than eight).
So things have deteriorated some (if you hadn’t noticed).
October 5th, 2012 on 4:08 pm
I noticed
October 5th, 2012 on 4:59 pm
Geezus. Things have deteriorated? I must have taken a nap.
October 5th, 2012 on 5:02 pm
Well, then. I don’t suppose he can play third? (Joke, Eric, Joke)
October 5th, 2012 on 5:07 pm
I hear age 35 is the best time to pick up a new position.
I give him about the same chance as Utley. Maybe they could be a left/left platoon where one of them plays day games and the other night. Or Utley could start when the other team’s starting pitcher’s last name started with ‘A’ through ‘M’ and Pierre could go when it started with ‘N’ through ‘Z’.
It makes about as much sense to me as starting Galvis at third, which I think they’re going to consider before it’s over.
Help.
October 5th, 2012 on 5:21 pm
Ok. The second paragraph made me laugh out loud. But you wouldn’t take that and be happy with it. Noooooooooo. You had to do that third paragraph. I think I need scotch. A LOT of scotch.
They cannot possibly try that. Not seriously. Not really. Can they?
October 5th, 2012 on 5:31 pm
Would you feel better with Galvis at SS and Rollins at third?
October 5th, 2012 on 6:53 pm
I’d feel better not using Galvis as a starter at all. Late inning defensive replacement only.
October 6th, 2012 on 5:22 pm
I’m rooting for the Orioles this year. It’s probably the kiss of death having me rooting for them, but I’d love to see Big Jim get a ring.
October 7th, 2012 on 5:15 pm
I would not be comfortable with Galvis on the field starting anywhere next year. I agree he’s a defensive replacement until he demonstrates he can hit. That’s going to be a problem for him, cause he can’t.
On the other hand, his UZR/150 at short last year was 77.1. That’s pretty impressive. Sadly just 36 1/3 innings, so I wouldn’t take that to the bank at this point.
I don’t think Rollins is playing anywhere but short any time soon.