Well, at least we got to see Papelbon in a tie game.
The Phillies have a bunch of problems in a bunch of areas these days, but the bullpen seems willing to go the extra mile to get itself noticed in a competitive environment. After several games where he stayed in the pen late in a tie game on the road, Papelbon pitched in a tie game at home last night. Didn’t go well. Entering with the score knotted at 2-2, Papelbon gave up a three-run home run to Jordany Valdespin and the Mets beat the Phils 5-2.
The Phillies have played 30 games this season. Over the first 14 games of the year, the bullpen pitched to a 2.01 ERA 31 1/3 innings. Over the last 16 games, Phillie relievers have thrown 39 innings in which they have pitched to a 7.15 ERA and a 1.69 ratio. Combine those results and you get the worst bullpen in baseball — at least by ERA. After allowing three runs in two innings last night, the bullpen ERA for the Phils for the year is up to 4.86. The Angels have the second-worst bullpen ERA at 4.76.
Over the last two games, we’ve now seen the Phillies hit Bryce Harper on purpose, say they did it on purpose, get suspended for it, cost themselves a run they didn’t have to spare on an interference call at second base because their runner was so far off the bag and into the shortstop the ump didn’t have much of a choice and put their shoulder into the catcher’s jaw on a play at the plate, knocking him out of the game.
Not sure if any of that is the kind of stuff that’s going to pull the Phillies out of their funk or not. It hasn’t so far.
The Phillies are 14-16 on the year after losing to the Mets 5-2 last night. Coming off of a 6-3 stretch, the Phils have lost three of four.
Halladay got the start for the Phillies and went seven innings, allowing two runs on five hits and a walk. One of the hits went for extra-bases, a double. He struck out seven and dropped his ERA on the year to 3.28. He has the fifth-best ERA among the six pitchers who have started games for the Phils this year.
He set the Mets down in order in the first. Andres Torres was the first batter of the game and ripped a ball to the gap in left-center, but Mayberry made a diving catch to record the out.
Halladay started the second with a 1-0 lead. Daniel Murphy singled to right with one out and stole second as Halladay struck out Ike Davis swinging for the second out. Justin Turner grounded out to leave Murphy at second.
Up 2-0, Halladay set the Mets down in order in the third, fourth and fifth.
He got Josh Thole to pop to Galvis for the first out in the sixth before lefty Mike Baxter hit for the pitcher Jon Niese. Baxter popped to Rollins for the second out before Halladay walked Andres Torres. Torres moved up to second on a single by Kirk Nieuwenhuis, putting men on first and second for David Wright. Wright doubled down the third base line, clearing the bases and tying the game at 2-2. Halladay struck Lucas Duda out swinging for the third out.
Davis singled with one out in the seventh. Halladay got Turner on a line drive to left for the second out before Thole moved Davis up to second with an infield single. Righty Scott Hairston hit for the pitcher Manny Acosta and popped a ball up in the infield, right behind the mound. Galvis made a nice sliding catch in front of Rollins to end the frame.
Bastardo started the eighth with the game still tied and walked Torres to start the inning. Nieuwenhuis bunted Torres to second with the first out. Bastardo walked the righty Wright intentionally, putting runners on first and second for Duda. Duda grounded into a double-play to set New York down.
Don’t remember Antonio Bastardo walking a lot of guys intentionally last year? Me neither. The intentional walk to Wright was the first he has issued in his career.
Bastardo hasn’t allowed a hit or a run over his last four appearances, each of which have been one full inning. Over those four outings, his ERA has dropped from 5.40 to 2.45. He has walked six in 7 1/3 innings for the season.
Papelbon started the ninth. He walked Ike Davis, who is 1-for-his-last-13 and hitting .173 on the year, with one out. Papelbon struck Turner out swinging for the second out before Mike Nickeas doubled to left, moving Davis up to third. Lefty Jordany Valdespin hit for the pitcher Tim Byrdak and hit an 0-1 pitch out to right, putting the Mets on top 5-2. Torres flew to left for the third out.
Papelbon’s ERA for the year rises from 0.82 to 3.00 with the outing. He allowed three home runs in 64 1/3 innings in 2011 and has allowed two so far in 12 innings in 2012.
Papelbon threw 30 pitches in the game and Bastardo 22.
The Phillies lineup against lefty Jon Niese went (1) Rollins (2) Mayberry (3) Victorino (4) Pence (5) Wigginton (6) Ruiz (7) Polanco (8) Galvis. Mayberry starts in left and second in the order for the first time on the season. Wigginton at first against the lefty.
Rollins led off the bottom of the first with a double and moving up to third on a bobble error by Torres. Mayberry was next and flew to center for the first out, deep enough for Rollins to tag and score, putting the Phillies on top 1-0. Victorino singled to left before Pence grounded to third with Victorino forced at second for the second out. Wigginton struck out looking to end the inning.
Ruiz walked to start the bottom of the second and scored when Polanco ripped a double to the gap in left-center. 2-0. Galvis was next and grounded to short for the first out. Polanco moved up to third, but Halladay struck out behind Galvis for the second out of the inning. Rollins struck out to leave Polanco at third.
No more runs for the Phils after putting Polanco on third with one out. Halladay strikes out with one down and a runner on third.
Victorino walked with one out in the third, but Pence and Wigginton both grounded out behind him.
Ruiz walked to start the fourth, but the Phils went in order behind him.
Mayberry singled to left with one out in the fifth. Victorino fouled out to Wright for the second out before Pence drew a walk, moving Mayberry up to second. Wigginton struck out swinging to leave both runners stranded.
It was 2-2 when righty Manny Acosta set the Phillies down in order in the sixth.
Righty Bobby Parnell started the seventh for the Mets. Pierre hit for Halladay and drew a walk. Rollins moved him to second with a single before Mayberry flew to right for the first out. Victorino reached on an infield single to load the bases for Pence. Pence grounded to second. The Mets went to second for one, but Pence just beat the relay to first. It would have been a run for the Phils as Pierre crossed the plate, but Victorino was called for interference at second. Victorino was out, Pence was out and the inning was over.
Victorino was way out of the base line at second.
Wigginton started the eighth with a single to center before Ruiz bunted for a hit, putting runners on first and second with nobody out. Polanco bunted the runners up to second and third with the first out. Galvis chopped a ball back to the pitcher. Parnell fielded and threw home as Wiggington arrived. Wigginton put his shoulder into Thole’s jaw, but somehow Thole hung onto the ball to retire the out. Thole had to leave the game and Nickeas came on to catch for New York. Lefty Tim Byrdak came on to pitch to the lefty Nix. Kratz hit for Nix and struck out swinging to leave the runners at first and third.
Amazing job by Thole to hang onto the ball. Big at-bat for Kratz, who got ahead 2-0, but went down swinging on a 3-2 pitch that was outside.
Righty Frank Francisco set the Phillies down in order in the ninth. Rollins was the first batter for the Phils and put a pretty bunt down the first base line, but Francisco made a nice play to get to the ball and Davis put on an acrobatic swiping tag to get Rollins for the first out.
Rollins was 2-for-5 with a double in the series. He has five extra-base hits in 127 plate appearances for the year and a slugging percentage of .274.
Mayberry 1-for-4 with an RBI and some nice defensive work in left.
Victorino 2-for-4 with a walk. 333/394/533 in 33 plate appearances so far in May.
Pence 0-for-3 with a walk and five men left on base. He has walked in about 4.8% of his plate appearances so far in 2012. His career rate is about 7.0% and his worst mark for any season is 5.4% in 2007.
Wigginton 1-for-4 with two strikeouts and four men left on base. He’s 1-for-his-last-13 with eight strikeouts.
Ruiz 1-for-2 with two walks. 372/417/721 over his last 48 plate appearances.
Polanco 1-for-3 with a double and an RBI. 364/391/455 over his last 47 plate appearances.
Galvis 0-for-4 with a strikeout and four men left on base. There are 111 NL players with at least 75 plate appearances — Galvis’s .215 on-base percentage is 110th and his .289 slugging percentage is 106th.
Blanton (3-3, 2.83) faces righty Miguel Batista (0-1, 6.92) tonight. Blanton was outstanding his last time out, throwing a complete-game shutout against the Braves. His 2.83 ERA is second-best among Phillie starters and he’s walked just three in 35 innings on the year. Bastista has mostly been appearing in relief for the Mets. He’s made one start on the year and that was a disaster as he allowed six runs over 3 2/3 innings against the Giants on April 23. He hasn’t gone more than 3 2/3 innings in any appearance this season.
Cole Hamels was suspended for five games.


May 8th, 2012 on 11:26 am
Paps in a tie game … file that under “be careful what you wish for”.
It’s not pretty, but hovering within a game or two of .500 is basically what we wanted/expected while we wait for the cavalry to arrive. Hopefully they’re on their way.
May 8th, 2012 on 11:39 am
I think that’s a good point. Coming into the season, I would have taken .500 after 40 games for sure. In addition to worrying about how soon the cavalry is going to arrive, I’m starting to worry about how much we’re going to need.
In the rotation, I think you have to worry about Lee on the DL. Halladay pitched well last night, but he doesn’t look right to me and hasn’t for two starts.
The pen is worse than I thought it would be. Papelbon is still great, but Qualls isn’t the answer in the eighth inning and Bastardo, although he’s been good of late, still looks like cause for worry. And there’s three or four guys out there in the pen who look like they don’t have much chance to help and the Phils don’t have three or four guys to replace them with. So the Phils need help out in the pen. Kendrick when Lee returns will be part of that, but I don’t think it’s enough.
May 8th, 2012 on 11:41 am
Pull the Phillies out of a funk. Anyone beginning to think that this is just who they are and that this is no funk?
May 8th, 2012 on 11:56 am
I have to agree. Utley & Howard are going to have to come back and be enough offense, because we need 2-3 more bullpen pieces than we have. Trade Blanton for some, sign Oswalt to be 5th starter, maybe trade Brown for some.
Lee is supposed to actually pitch this week. We’ll see how that goes.
May 8th, 2012 on 12:47 pm
I think the offense isn’t a funk. That’s just what they are. They can and will be a little better without new hitters, but not a whole lot.
I think the bullpen can and will get a lot better. Partly because the guys pitching in the pen now will be better and because they will add pieces. The team can win if the offense is pretty good, the pen is pretty good and the starting pitching is great. Right now the offense is bad, the pen is the worst in baseball and the starters are good. That gives the Phils just about no chance. But — the pen’s a lock to get better, the starters should get better relative to the rest of the league and so should the offense. Just a question of how much better and how soon.
May 8th, 2012 on 3:35 pm
Well, it is certainly true that the pen could hardly be worse. One hopes it has to get better.
A lot rides on Lee being ok pretty soon, too. Kendrick in the pen should help.
May 8th, 2012 on 8:31 pm
Joe doing ok so far.
May 8th, 2012 on 9:22 pm
I can’t believe the garbage failed rundown I just saw.
…
Why is Orr starting? Certainly his offensive upgrade over Galvis isn’t worth his embarrassing defense?
May 8th, 2012 on 9:24 pm
Qualls just worked his magic. The magician’s assistant is Orr. Bastardo adds his bit.
I think we could get reasonable odds the the Phillies will be sellers at the deadline.
May 8th, 2012 on 9:29 pm
I cringed when the announcer said the Q-word too. But we still should have been out of the inning with the game tied.
May 8th, 2012 on 9:37 pm
Shoulda been up two if Q just gets one guy out. Just one. Jeepers.
May 8th, 2012 on 9:49 pm
At least it was against a righty. Qualls giving it up to another lefty would have been too much for me.
May 8th, 2012 on 10:01 pm
The 8th just makes me nuts. Our half I mean.
Is it too weird the Rod Barajas beat the Nats in the 9th?
May 8th, 2012 on 10:18 pm
Just possibly our earlier thesis that the bull pen could not get worse was wrong.
May 9th, 2012 on 8:30 am
And after that whatever-that-was last night, Lee’s pitching tonight with a pitch count. Getting swept at home by the Mets with the bullpen going 0-3 is a real possibility.
May 9th, 2012 on 8:32 am
Wasnt crazy to hear Cholly in post game comments say he doesnt know what to say to this team either. Someone’s gotta step up and take a lead. The whole team just seems flat. Imagine if the starting pitching was as bad as the offense/bullpen, I doubt the Phils would have more than 3 wins, seriously.
The number of IronPigs on this team is really troublesome.
Can I take something away from Mayberry seeming to have a decent night? no? alright then…
May 9th, 2012 on 9:35 am
Jimmy used to be the leader, or so we thought. Not any longer, not until he puts his bat where his mouth is. But who takes the leadership from him? Hard to see anyone there do that.
And I get Charlie. Amaro handed him a team that is just not very good. What can he say but that? And he cannot really say that out loud.
What I DO NOT get is why no one in Philly is calling Amaro out. This is his mess. He is the one who went into this season with his 3 and 4 hole hitters out for what may only seem like forever, no reliable offense from 3rd base or left field and did not address the black hole any fool could see would be there.
Amaro’s decisions are utterly incomprehensible to me.
May 9th, 2012 on 10:08 am
If you want to blame RAJ for something, blame him for the Howard contact. More than anything, that seems to be tying his hands right now, as ownership is showing zero interest in paying a penny of luxury tax, and we would certainly have to pay to get non-replacement players on the field.
May 9th, 2012 on 10:28 am
Yeah, I get the Howard contract thing.
If the luxury tax thing is really an issue for them, then they are wasting a heck of a lot of money this year in bringing high priced pitching to town.
And just a little side note about cash flow and the Phillies. Up until this year I could sell my tickets on StubHub for more than face value, often twice or even three times face value. Prices on StubHub are sliding big time. Pretty soon they park will not be filling up unless they do something.
Expect Hamels to be gone at the deadline.
May 9th, 2012 on 11:16 am
I think you can definitely blame Amaro for the Papelbon contract as well.
$46 million for Utley, Howard and Rollins makes things tough, especially if Howard and Utley aren’t going to play and Rollins is going to be horrid.
I think you can fault the team for thinking Mayberry and Galvis are good enough to play everyday at this point. I don’t think they are. Polanco has been great lately, but I think the Phillies need to get more out of their 3B.
And the bullpen is bad. Not this bad, but there are too many wishful thinking guys out there.