The Phillies got their first start of the season that wasn’t fantastic yesterday, but otherwise things looked just about the same. Not much offense and a defensive miscue that led an unearned run the Phils can’t afford to allow if they aren’t going to score.
There were some offensive highlights to the game as well. Freddy Galvis registered his first career hit, doubling to the gap in left-center to drive a pair of runs.
The other highlight was that the Phillies didn’t bunt in the game. Not once. No Laynce Nix popping the bunt up. No Jimmy Rollins bunting out of the three-hole, no seeing the third hitter in a scoreless game try to bunt the runners along. Of course, a lot of that probably had something to do with being way behind for much of the game, but this is no time to quibble.
For the second straight game, the Phillies had a defensive lapse at first base that led to at least one earned run. In Sunday’s game, Wigginton failed to handle Schneider’s throw to first on a would-be strikeout, which led to a pair of unearned runs. In yesterday’s game, neither Galvis nor Mayberry was there to cover first when Emilio Bonifacio bunted back to the mound. Hamels threw the ball into right field, allowing Bonifacio to take third. Bonifacio scored two batters later.
The Phillies are 1-3 on the year after losing 6-2 to the Miami Marlins yesterday. They have lost three in a row.
Hamels got the start for the Phillies and went 5 1/3 innings, allowing four runs on eight hits. Only three of the runs were earned. Four of the hits went for extra-bases, three doubles and a home run. He struck out nine.
At least it was better than his first start of 2011.
Switch-hitter Jose Reyes was the first hitter of the game and he singled into right. Switch-hitter Emilio Bonifacio followed with a single to left that put men on first and second with nobody out for righty Hanley Ramirez. Reyes and Bonifacio pulled off a double-steal as the count went 0-2 on Ramirez. With the infield back, Ramirez grounded softly to second. Ramirez was just out at first, Reyes scored to make it 1-0 with one down and Bonifacio on first. Righty Gaby Sanchez was next and Hamels struck him out swinging 2-2 for the second out. Righty Austin Kearns struck out swinging 1-2 to leave Bonifacio at third.
Back-to-back strikeouts by Hamels keep Bonifacio at third.
Lefty Chris Coghlan led off the top of the second and struck out swinging at a ball in the dirt for the first out. Righty Omar Infante went down on a line drive to third. Righty John Buck struck out swinging 0-2 for the third out.
Four strikeouts for Hamels through two innings. He had struck out four of the last five batters he had faced.
The pitcher Anibal Sanchez led off the third and grounded to third, with Polanco bouncing the throw over to Mayberry for the first out. Reyes was next and tried to bunt for a hit, but Ruiz popped out on it nicely and threw to first for the second out. Bonifacio struck out looking 1-2 to set Miami down.
Eight in a row for Hamels, who had thrown 41 pitches.
Ramirez led off the fourth with a double to left. Sanchez was next and singled into right. Ramirez scored easily, extending the Miami lead to 2-0. Hamels got behind Kearns 3-0, but came back to strike him out looking 3-2 for the first out. Coghlan grounded to short, with the Phillies turning the double-play to set the Fish down.
Infante led off the fifth and hit an 0-1 pitch out to left, extending the lead to 3-0. Hamels struck Buck and Sanchez both out behind Infante before Reyes lined a double to left. Ruiz threw Reyes out trying to steal third with Bonifacio at the plate to end the frame.
You don’t usually want to make the first or third or any out trying to steal third. Hamels allowed a career-best 0.79 home runs per nine innings in 2011, which was the best year of his career. So let’s hope we don’t see the ball going out of the yard too often in the early going. Infante didn’t hit it way out, but he did hit it through the wind.
Bonifacio bunted back to the mound to start the sixth. Hamels fielded and threw to first where nobody was covering. Hamels was charged with an error on the throw and Bonifacio went all the way to third while the Phils chased the ball around the outfield. Ramirez struck out looking for the first out, but Sanchez was next and doubled down the left field line, scoring Bonifacio to make it 4-0. That was it for Hamels and Joe Savery came on to pitch to the righty Kearns. Savery got behind Kearns 2-0 before Kearns grounded to third on a 2-1 pitch for the second out with Sanchez holding second. Coghlan followed and grounded to second on a nice play by Galvis for the third out.
Nice start to the year for Savery in the sixth, keeping more runs off the board after entering with one out and a man on second.
Galvis or Mayberry needs to cover first on the play. The ball was hit pretty straight back to Hamels, so I’ll go with Mayberry if we have to pick one. Either way, it draws attention to the fact that the Phils started two guys on the right side of their infield in the game with very little experience at the position. Cost the Phillies a run.
Savery came back to start the seventh and Infante led off by hitting a 1-1 pitch out to left for his second homer of the day. 5-0. Savery got Buck and Sanchez on a pair of ground balls before Reyes popped to Mayberry for the third out.
It was 5-2 when Herndon started the eighth. He was pitching for the second straight day after throwing 20 pitches in game three in Pittsburgh. Bonifacio led off and singled on a ball that was deflected by Polanco. Ramirez was next and he hit into a double-play, clearing the bases for Sanchez. Herndon got Sanchez swinging 2-2 to set the Fish down.
Papelbon started the ninth for the Phils, making his second appearance of the year and first since Opening Day. Kearns led off and homered to left. 6-2. Papelbon got the next three, getting Coghlan on a ground ball to the mound, Infante on a fly ball to right and striking Buck out swinging.
The Phils did not use Papelbon in the eighth inning of Sunday’s game, which they led 4-3 with two outs and men on first and second before righty Matt Hague singled off of the lefty Bastardo. They do use Papelbon yesterday trailing by three runs in the top of the ninth.
I think if they had that to do over, they might do it differently.
The pen went 3 2/3 innings in the game, allowing two runs on three hits (including two solo homers) and no walks.
Herndon has pitched two days in a row. He threw 13 pitches in the game. Papelbon 18 and Savery 15. None of that will matter much with the Phillies not playing today.
At least we know now that Manuel is aware Savery is on the team.
The Phillies lineup against righty Anibal Sanchez went (1) Pierre (2) Polanco (3) Rollins (4) Pence (5) Victorino (6) Mayberry (7) Ruiz (8) Galvis. Pierre leads off against a righty for the second-straight game and plays left. The righty Mayberry at first with Wigginton, Nix and Thome on the bench. Victorino hits fifth in the order after leading off and hitting out of the one and two spots in the series against the Pirates. Glad to see Victorino dropped to lower in the order — the Phillies are going to need him to drive in some runs. Against a righty, it seems clear to me that Thome is the best offensive option the Phillies have at first base (although it’s pretty likely we’re not going to see him start in back-to-back days). Less clear between Mayberry, Nix and Wigginton, although I would probably go with the lefty Nix. On the other hand, Mayberry doesn’t have nearly the career plate appearances that Nix and Wigginton do, so it’s a little harder to know what he might do. Polanco really shouldn’t hit second.
The Phils were down 1-0 when Pierre led off the bottom of the first and flew to left. Polanco grounded to short before Rollins singled into center, putting a man on first for Pence. Rollins stole second as the count when 1-1 on Pence. Pence popped to Infante in shallow left to leave Rollins at second.
Victorino grounded to first to start the second. Mayberry struck out looking 2-2 for the second out. Ruiz popped out to Kearns in shallow right field to set the Phils down.
Galvis and Hamels both struck out looking on a total of six pitches to start the third. Pierre grounded to second to end the inning.
Polanco and Rollins both grounded out to start the fourth before Pence singled into center. Victorino followed that up by walking on four pitches, putting men on first and second for Mayberry. Mayberry flew to right to leave both runners stranded.
The Phils were down 3-0 when they hit in the fifth. Ruiz, Galvis and Hamels went in order.
It was 4-0 when Pierre grounded to third for the first out of the sixth. Polanco was next and struck out swinging 3-2. Rollins singled into center and took second on a balk by Sanchez before Pence flew to Bonifacio in left center.
They started the bottom of the seventh down 5-0. Victorino led off with a single to right. Mayberry was next and he singled hard to left center, moving Victorino up to second. Ruiz hit a ball softly to first where it was short-hopped by Sanchez. Mayberry was caught up between first and second and thrown out at second, putting men on first and third with one down for Galvis. Galvis hit for himself and cleared the bases with a double to left center, getting the Phils on the board at 5-2. Nix hit for Savery. Lefty Randy Choate took over for the Marlins. Wigginton hit for Nix and Choate struck him out swinging for the second out. Pierre lined to short for the third out.
First career hit for Galvis. Came at a good time. I would have hit for him.
Victorino’s single was the first runner for the game for the Phils that came with less than two outs. Pierre has to hit for himself against the lefty cause the Phillies only had one right-handed hitter on their bench, Wigginton, and he had already struck out.
While on the subject, Frank Gailey’s first outing with Clearwater didn’t go that well either as Gailey was charged with two runs in 1 1/3 innings.
Righty Edward Mujica started the eighth for Miami. Polanco flew to right, Rollins struck out swinging and Pence grounded hard back to the mound.
And that was that for 2-3-4 in the order.
Righty Steve Cishek started the ninth for the Marlins with a 6-2 lead. He struck Victorino out looking 0-2 for the first out. Mayberry grounded to second for the second. Ruiz struck out swinging to end the game.
Pierre was 0-for-4 in the game and is 2-for-9 on the year.
Polanco 0-for-4 and 2-for-13.
Rollins 2-for-4 with two singles to up his average to .250 (4-for-16). Also stole his first base of the season.
Pence 1-for-4 and left two men on base. 4-for-15 for the year. His .886 OPS leads the team — he and Ruiz are the only two hitters with an OPS over .745. Halladay, 1-for-3 with a single on the season, is fourth on the team in OPS at .667.
Victorino 1-for-3 with a walk.
Mayberry 1-for-4 with a strikeout. 3-for-12 with a double, no walks and four strikeouts.
Ruiz 0-for-4 to drop his average to .400 (4-for-10).
Galvis 1-for-3 with a two-run double. He’s one of three Phillies with an extra-base hit for the season (Pence, Mayberry, Galvis).
Halladay (1-0, 0.00) faces righty Josh Johnson (0-1, 4.50) on Wednesday. Halladay allowed two singles in eight shutout innings against the Pirates on Opening Day. Johnson allowed three runs on ten hits and two walks over six innings in his first start of the season, which came against St Louis.
Eric Pettis, who pitched for Lakewood and Clearwater in 2011 and Williamsport in 2010, has written a book about his experience in the minors. This link is to the Kindle ebook version from Amazon. He was recently interviewed at Phillies Nation.


April 10th, 2012 on 10:13 am
More than anything else, I think what’s hurting this team is 1st base defense. There’s guys we can have stand there, but the only guy that actually knows how to play it and didn’t get hurt in the last game of the 2011 season can only play 6 innings a week. If I’m RAJ, I’m looking for a Meintiewicz type to fill Orr’s or Wigginton’s roster spot and start at first until such time as Howard gets back.
Pitching & defense will get you a lot further than pitching & offense (with no D).. especially when nobody you can have stand at 1st right now is a significant dropoff from a pure defensive 1st baseman anyway.
April 10th, 2012 on 10:29 am
The first base defense has been bad, but I’d put never, ever scoring runs higher on the list of Phillies problems. It’s not sustainable that the Phillies are going to have a defensive blunder at first every game. It’s really sustainable that Galvis, Polanco and Pierre aren’t going to hit very well and that Wigginton, Nix and Mayberry look like their upsides are around average or maybe a little bit better under perfect circumstances.
I think we should be worried about the bullpen, too, which hasn’t looked real good in the early going.
April 10th, 2012 on 12:35 pm
Well, I’m kind of under the assumption that there’s just no offense to be had. We might be able to trade for Jason Bay, but I’m not even sure that does anything for us.
That said, I’d rather win 1-0, than lose 3-2 with 2 unearned runs due to someone getting lost at first base. And they say, defense don’t slump.
I’m actually not worried about the bullpen, yet. It seems more to me that they’re getting put in positions they shouldn’t be in (due to bad D or due to bunting with your 3-hole hitter), and may not be on top of their game as a result.
April 10th, 2012 on 1:06 pm
I think the offense is so bad they don’t need to get back good players to improve it. They need to get back average players to improve it. I was joking about Ben Francisco, who they gave away, in the post. But Ben Francisco (if he wasn’t on the DL) would help. Here’s a not-so-fun game: fill in the blank: If Ben Francisco was on the Phillies right now, he would be the ____th best hitter on the team. Thome, Pence and Victorino are clearly better than Francisco. After that my guess is that opinions would vary.
Edit — oops, Francisco off the DL already and 0-for-1 on the year.
April 10th, 2012 on 1:33 pm
Interesting. I’d probably put Benny Fresh around 7th, after the 3 you mentioned plus Chooch, JRoll, and Mayberry. But I’ve never been his biggest fan. If Brown were on the bigs I’d put him in front of Ben too.
April 10th, 2012 on 1:44 pm
I think that’s fair. I think it gets pretty fuzzy after Thome, Pence and Victorino. Mayberry has clearly been better as has Rollins, but I feel less certain they will be better offensively this year than Francisco would given a large number of chances. Agree about Brown, who is 3-for-13 with two walks so far at Triple-A (hopefully with sparkling defense, although I’m kinda skeptical).
April 10th, 2012 on 2:23 pm
On the subject of Eric Pettis and his book, he was also recently released. For those conspiracy theorists out there, it wasn’t long after the book was released that he was released. Personally, I think it was because he wasn’t that great of a pitcher, but we’ll never really know.
On the major league team, I’m not too worried about the bull pen either. The offense is my worry. That and I really don’t see any way that things are going to improve in the near term.
April 10th, 2012 on 2:41 pm
The guys I’m not worried about in the bullpen are as follows: Papelbon. Everyone else seems kinda scary. Bastardo can be solid without being nearly as good as he was in 2011. Everyone else seems to me to be a candidate to get bombed this year.
Also, it’s just four games, but they sure have pitched a lot given that three of the four starts were made by Halladay, Lee and Hamels. Obviously it’s a very tiny number of games, but through three of them the Phils have thrown an average of 2.78 innings per game in the games started by those three pitchers compared to 2.02 in 2011. The Phillies can get away with having a mediocre bullpen by not using it very much — more innings would be a problem.
April 10th, 2012 on 3:43 pm
They my be able to make the offense better by getting only better players, but do they win unless they get players who are actually good? given the payroll, isn’t the front office hoping for more than just making the offense marginally better?
April 10th, 2012 on 4:22 pm
I think it depends a lot on what the truth is about Utley and Howard. The Phillies are going to need good players before it’s over, but there are two of them right there. If the Phillies think they are really coming back, I don’t think they need to go out and pay for really good players. They need players that will allow them to keep it close enough that Utley and Howard can still push them over the top when they get back.
If Utley and Howard aren’t coming back, the Phillies need to add good players.
April 10th, 2012 on 8:30 pm
The Phillies are in deep crap. I’m an idiot so I go with intuition for sports. Utley is done. Howard is needed but also has problems especially late in the season when his leg support goes to hit the baseball. Look at what he does (a lot) the last few years. Sure he has Hall numbers but soft grounders and strikeouts are killers with him. Pence is good but not something you can build around..he swings like a crazy man. Polanco and Rollins? umm..can I whisper..old. Rollins wasn’t ever a .300 hitter anyway. Jim Thome? right. The least of their problems is the bullpen where set up relief will be an issue. The Phils will be lucky to get a wildcard. I am a lifelong fan. Just stating what I know and intuition. Oh yeah, Manuel is the worst guy to to have of all with this squad, and what they need to go all the way..not 2008 and career wins, he deserves recognition, but NOW.
April 10th, 2012 on 10:13 pm
Breakings news: Phillies failed to lose a game today.
I really don’t see the strength of the NL East. I see a bunch of 75-85 win teams. Any of them can pop up and take the division. There won’t be a wildcard from the NL East.
April 11th, 2012 on 9:05 am
But will they fail to lose a game today?
Let’s hope so. Great pitching matchup tonight. Should be a good game.
I don’t think it’s time to panic. The team by the end of the year is going to look a whole lot different than it does now. Obviously it’s important to win as many games now as they can, cause it means less work they’ll need to do later.
April 11th, 2012 on 7:11 pm
Not time to panic. Agreed. A win tonight would really help the mood of this part of the world.
April 11th, 2012 on 7:16 pm
Vic. 1st inning catch. The man does have leather.
April 11th, 2012 on 7:39 pm
That was nice. Halladay needed it to with another odd first inning. Time to hit.
April 11th, 2012 on 8:07 pm
Yikes. Pierre was called safe for that steal. I will take it. No pride here.
April 11th, 2012 on 8:08 pm
TIE SCORE, YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
April 11th, 2012 on 8:12 pm
Rollins. Ribbie. a lead. against Johnson.
April 11th, 2012 on 8:34 pm
FREDDIE. Well, THAT was fun.
April 11th, 2012 on 8:37 pm
Indeed. Five runs. One game. Cool they were chanting Freddy before the double. People are going to notice the bat-flip.
April 11th, 2012 on 9:14 pm
Ya think that Jimmy will have to rub Freddie’s belly everytime now before an at bat?
April 11th, 2012 on 9:53 pm
Whatever it takes.
April 11th, 2012 on 10:03 pm
So, if Doc can start 103 games this year, do you think the Phillies can set a new win record?
April 11th, 2012 on 10:05 pm
That might actually be the only way it could happen.
April 12th, 2012 on 9:21 am
I’ve made a decision. If Galvis wants to hit .150, but every hit is a 2-run double, I’m ok with that.