Overall in 2011, the Phillies finished a disappointing seventh in the NL in runs scored. Things picked up a lot towards the end of the year, though — from the start of July to the end of the regular season, the Phils led the NL in runs score.
When you think about how things went month-to-month for the Phils in 2011, it’s important to remember that the offense had two terrible months early in the year that dragged the numbers down for the season. After a solid start to the year in April, the offense dropped like a stone for the Phils in May as the team finished twelfth in the NL in runs scored for the month. They followed that up with a June in which they were eleventh in the NL in runs scored. After the first three full months of the season, the Phils were eighth in the league in runs scored. But things got better in a hurry.
The table below shows, for each month of the 2011 season, the Phillies rank in run scored for the league for that month, their rank in runs scored from the beginning of the season through the end of that month and their rank in runs scored in the league from the end of that month to the end of the regular season.
| Month | NL Rank RS for Month | Rank RS start of season thru month | Rank RS after month to end of season |
| April | 4 | 4 | 6 |
| May | 12 | 8 | 4 |
| June | 11 | 8 | 1 |
| July | 1 | 6 | 4 |
| August | 3 | 6 | 6 |
| Sept | 6 | 7 | - |
So, for example, in May of 2011, the Phils were twelfth in the NL in runs scored. From the start of the season through the end of May, they were eighth in the NL in runs scored and from the end of May to the end of the regular season they were fourth.
| Through end of June | July to end of season | May and June | April, July, August and September | |
| PHI NL Rank Runs Scored | 8 | 1 | 12 | 2 |
Again, two bad months. Start of the season through June they were eighth in the NL in runs scored. Start of July to the end of the season they were first. In May and June combined they were twelfth. In all of the months except May and June combined they were second.
Here’s a look back at some of the monthly performances that helped contribute to the numbers above:
The offense was solid in April, fourth in the NL in runs scored.
Howard led the team in home runs (six) and RBI (27), hitting 291/351/560. Polanco was a monster, too, hitting 398/447/524 in the only month of the season in which he would put up an OPS of .700 or better. After going 2-for-3 with a double against the Mets on April 30, Polanco would hit 243/304/287 in 409 plate appearances for the rest of the season.
Ibanez was atrocious for the Phils in April, posting a 161/247/218 line over 97 plate appearances. Valdez started 19 games and hit 239/282/284.
It wouldn’t last, but Francisco put up solid numbers for April, hitting 266/347/447 for the month and starting 24 games. Things were already looking a little less than fabulous for Francisco, though. After hitting 308/386/513 over 44 plate appearances to start the season, Francisco hit 236/317/400 over the last 16 games of the month.
In May the offense tanked. Eleven NL teams scored more runs than the Phillies in May.
The good news for May was that Ibanez bounced back dramatically, hitting a team-high seven homers and also leading the team in RBI with 19 as he posted a 315/339/602 line.
The bad news was pretty much everything else. Howard hit .208. Rollins on-based .306. Polanco on-based .289 with three extra-base hits in 27 starts. Utley was back at the end of the month, but not helping much. He hit 222/364/370 in 33 May plate appearances.
Francisco couldn’t hit enough to keep the right field job and was out of the lineup regularly during the second half of the month after hitting .103 (really! .103) in his first 50 plate appearances in May (4-for-39 with four singles). It created some openings in the outfield. Mayberry couldn’t capitalize, hitting 194/275/319 in his 80 May plate appearances, but Brown looked a little better. Brown appeared in just ten games in May (seven starts), but hit 333/378/545 in limited action (37 PA).
June was almost as bad as May. The Phils were eleventh in runs scored in the league in June. The team hit .229 for the month and slugged .317 — both would be lows for the season.
Howard was solid enough, leading the team with five homers and 22 RBI. He walked 18 times, putting up a .397 on-base percentage despite hitting just .269. Victorino pounded the ball to the tune of 297/383/505. So did Utley, who would hit 295/378/511 from the start of June to the end of July over 218 plate appearances. In June he posted a 297/387/473 line.
There was more than enough bad news to make up for it, though. Brown became nearly an everyday player in June, starting 22 games and hitting a meager 165/258/354 for the month. Mayberry went 0-for-3 in his four plate appearances for the month. Rollins on-based .314. Ruiz hit .221 and Polanco .213 — that duo combined for five extra-base hits in 194 June plate appearances. Ibanez’s May magic was gone as he hit a paltry 211/258/311 in his second atrocious month with the bat on the year.
The Phillies had their best offense month of the year in July, plating an NL-best 138 runs.
Ibanez was back, hitting seven home runs and driving in 25 with a 284/320/558 line. The 25 RBI he would post in July was the most of any Phillie for any month in 2011 other than Howard’s 27 in April.
Rollins found his power stroke as well, socking six home runs of his own with a 312/375/523 line. Utley had his best month of the year: 293/369/545 with five bombs. Victorino missed a lot of the month with a thumb injury, but was awesome when he played to the tune of 364/462/600 in 66 plate appearances for the month.
Victorino’s injury opened up a lot of time for Mayberry in center and Mayberry delivered with the bat. He came into July having hit 231/316/365 in 117 plate appearances for the year, but blasted a pair of home runs against the Fish on July 6 and hit 300/327/640 for the month in 52 plate appearances. Brown, meanwhile, continued to get chances, starting 20 games. He bounced back from a miserable June in which he hit .165, hitting 296/398/366, but without a home run in 83 plate appearances. Pence would arrive at the end of the month, securing right field for the rest of the season as he hit and hit and hit.
Ruiz, who would hit 317/391/425 in 251 plate appearances from the start of July to the end of the year, started his tear with what would be his best month of the season, hitting 324/432/485 in July.
Howard didn’t join the July party for the Phils, hitting .250 with a .306 on-base percentage, walking just eight times, which was his lowest mark for any month of the season. Martinez started 17 games for the Phils in July, primarily at third, and put up what were by far his best numbers for any month with a 247/300/384 line in 81 plate appearances. Those numbers for Martinez don’t sound great, but it’s important to remember that the Phils primary third baseman, Polanco, on-based .335 and slugged just .339 for the season.
In August the Phils were still hitting, if off the July pace a little. They were third in the NL in runs scored in August.
It was Pence’s first full month with the Phils and he was hitting everything. He hit seven home runs in August, posting a 340/413/596 line over 109 plate appearances.
Victorino was back, playing regularly and still hitting. 316/393/600 in August. Between June 17 and September 2, Victorino got 233 plate appearances in which he posted a stupid 325/409/611 line.
Ruiz continued to hit, too, 329/365/429 in August.
Valdez started 15 games, filling in primarily for Rollins and Polanco, and put up an unexpected 278/322/481 line over 59 plate appearances.
Off were Utley, 245/315/347, and Ibanez, 225/254/323. Mayberry started to see some more time in left — he got just 59 plate appearances in August, but made them memorable by homering six times as he put up a 296/356/685 line. Howard blasted eight homers and drove in 22 runs, but hit just .225 while doing so.
The Phillies were sixth in the NL in runs scored in September.
Pence continued to pound the ball, hitting 317/385/548 and leading the team with 18 RBI for the month. Howard hit 290/417/522. Mayberry got 13 more starts and hit 305/382/508 for the month. In his last 177 plate appearances on the year, Mayberry had hit 302/356/611. Polanco was back and at least got on base, hitting 280/349/344 in September. He ended the season having slugged .287 over his last 477 plate appearances.
Victorino and Utley both ended the year on a downswing. Victorino hit 186/258/319 in 125 plate appearances in September. Utley hit just 205/295/337. Martinez started 13 games and hit .136. After on-basing .368 in July and August combined, Rollins on-based just .308 in September.
The Phillies signed righty Dave Bush and lefty David Purcey to minor league deals and invited them to spring training. Bush is still just 32 and had pretty good years with the Brewers as a starter in 2006 and again in 2008. The lefty Purcey was good for the Blue Jays in a relief role in 2010, throwing to a 3.71 ERA with a 1.21 ratio, before getting hit hard with three teams in 2011.
Rafael Furcal agreed to a deal with the Cardinals, meaning Jimmy Rollins is running out of teams other than the Phils to play for.
Update: The Phillies have traded Ben Francisco to the Blue Jays for left-handed pitcher Frank Gailey. Gailey turned 26 last month and has never appeared in the majors. In 304 1/3 innings in the minors he has thrown to a 2.45 ERA with a 1.03 ratio. He has never pitched above Double-A.


December 12th, 2011 on 12:59 pm
I guess we dont count on Benny-Fresh next season…
http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/phillies/Phillies-trade-Francisco.html
December 12th, 2011 on 1:11 pm
Ben Francisco was just traded to Blue Jays for a minor league reliever..
Ok, now to read Eric’s post.
December 12th, 2011 on 1:23 pm
Golly. Let’s hope for the best, but it’s a little tough to feel like Gailey can help the Phils. Just turned 26 and has never pitched above Double-A isn’t a good sign. Threw to a 5.70 ERA in 30 innings at Double-A last year in his only action at Double-A.
December 12th, 2011 on 1:29 pm
Ouch, sorry Jim but the update wasnt posted when I read the post. Amazingly in this word of immediate information, there still can be time lapses…
December 12th, 2011 on 1:40 pm
You wanna talk about time lapse? Not only did Eric not staple the update to the end of the post, but I was the only comment.. yours wasn’t up….
December 12th, 2011 on 1:44 pm
If your comment includes a link, it has to be approved manually before it will appear. That’s why Bill’s comment wasn’t up even though he submitted it first.
December 12th, 2011 on 1:54 pm
No problem. Eric, feel free to remove my first comment and others related to it if you want, it does look dumb being that the same information is in the article.
December 12th, 2011 on 1:57 pm
I am fine with that move, if anything just to get rid of that OF Log Jam, I was hoping they would do something like that.
Re the post…I kept going back and looking at BA’s and OBP for the playoffs and reason…and of course as no surprise Hunter and Ryan were not so hot.
And I think part of the reason is we went Hunter 3 and Howard 4…it worked in game 1 and then nothing.
Assuming we get Jimmy and have a healthy Polly…I am fine with Jimmy, Polly, Utley, Howard, Pence Vic as the top 6. I think that type of lineup will help the #4 and 5 considerably.
December 12th, 2011 on 1:59 pm
PS- do you guys know when we hear about the outcome of Ryan Braun’s appeal?
December 12th, 2011 on 2:13 pm
I was just looking at some names from past trades I wonder which of these guys will work out the best in the Majors.
(note I don’t really consider Gio a Philly Farm System Product)
-Carlos Carrasco
-Jason Donald
-Lou Marson
-Michael Taylor
-Kyle Drabek
-JA Happ
-Jason Knapp
-Travis d’Arnaud
December 12th, 2011 on 2:47 pm
From that group, I’d go with d’Arnaud. You don’t get that kind of a player as a catcher very often.
Carrasco just had TJ surgery, and Knapp has had a bunch of shoulder surgeries already, so they are out. Donald is a solid utility infielder and Marson a backup catcher. Taylor may never hit. Happ is on the Astros.
Drabek still has a shot I think, but he needs to stop walking everybody.
Personally, I think the guys that we will miss the most were traded in the Oswalt and Pence trades (both not listed here). Anthony Gose has a chance to be Carl Crawford, only in center. Singleton and Cosart will be major leaguers. Domingo Santana could be awesome or he could flame out in AA. Still not sure about him.
December 12th, 2011 on 3:11 pm
Travis d’Arnaud hit 311/371/542 at Double-A last year, so his future is looking pretty bright. I still think Drabek will be very good. I think Knapp has good upside if he can stay healthy. I don’t expect a lot from Marson, Donald or Taylor. Still haven’t given up on Happ, despite his 2011.
December 12th, 2011 on 3:20 pm
I agree on Happy, always was a fan.
Anthony Gose…hmm…will remember that name.
December 12th, 2011 on 4:29 pm
So, according to the stats, the Phillies were really something special 4 out of 6 months. Is that the real Phillies team? Or is the real Phillies team the one that has hit/produced barely above the Mendoza Line for the past 5 post season events (that is over the past THREE years, if you’re counting)?
December 12th, 2011 on 4:56 pm
Brewers sign Ramirez. I am officially bummed.
December 13th, 2011 on 10:29 am
Being reported that the Phils signed Dontrelle Willis.
To which I say – Watcha talkin bout? Willis???
December 13th, 2011 on 10:58 am
Would be an interesting sign if true. Certainly a cheaper option as your number 4 starter than Oswalt would have been.
December 13th, 2011 on 11:29 am
Golly. Didn’t see that one coming.
http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/7347989/2011-free-agency-cincinnati-reds-dontrelle-willis-philadelphia-phillies-agree-source-says
Definitely cheaper than Oswalt, but I think it’s kind of a poor idea. 5.65 ERA in 78 appearances (75 starts) since the end of 2006 and has walked 243 in 404 1/3 innings pitched. Righties on-based .395 against him last year, but he did get out lefties. Having some trouble getting too excited about that one, but will hope for the best.
Maybe he’ll pitch out of the bullpen? Two years in a row he’s been really good against lefties. Pretty wary of him as a starter.
December 13th, 2011 on 11:46 am
Thinking about it more, I think the Phils must think that they can use him as a lefty out of the bullpen. Otherwise it’s just baffling to me. Will be interesting to see how it develops, but if Willis is willing to be a lefty specialist I think he could help the Phils.
December 13th, 2011 on 12:03 pm
Linked article suggests all the interest he’s been seeing is out of the pen. I’m good with him being a lefty specialist / 7th starter.
December 13th, 2011 on 12:50 pm
Eric, I appreciate the security concerns, but I think the word L-I-N-K is sending my comments to moderation-land
December 13th, 2011 on 2:02 pm
Thanks, Jim. That took a while to figure out. The blocked word was actually S-P-E-C-I-A-L-I-S-T and not L-I-N-K. I knew something was amiss when I had to manually approve my recent comment above, but it took a while to figure out which word was causing the problem.
Bonus points for whoever can figure out why specialist was accidentally blacklisted — FYI, the way it works is that if you ban any part of the word it can’t appear. For example, if you ban “copy” the word “copyright” could not appear.
Anyway, things should be working okay now, so feel free to use specialist as needed.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:02 pm
I’m on board with this move. I like the D-Train coming out as a specialist for lefties.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:10 pm
I’m a little surprised that Willis is willing to pitch out of the pen. He’s made 205 appearances in his career and 202 of them have been starts. He’s still just 29-years-old. Like I said above, if he’s really willing to be a lefty specialist I think he could be good. Lefties hit 127/169/200 against him in 2011 after hitting 216/298/284 against him in 2010.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:30 pm
I actually work in Pharma, so it’s not fair for me to point out the moderation problem..
I do love partial-word censorship though.. on some boards, you can’t talk about grapes.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:32 pm
CIA List?
I like the signing too…I never had a problem with the guy and like you said…its only 29. Finished 2nd in Cy Yong at what 22 23 years old? Let’s give him a shot…he seems healthy…in 2011 had a lot of starts between ML and Minors, so his arm must be ok…just does not quite have what he used to. Wasn’t Dennis Eckersly a starting pitcher that went to the pen?
The best part is its a very cheap signing.
Was he on a 1 year deal with Cincy?
December 13th, 2011 on 2:53 pm
Close.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:36 pm
At least if he is going to be a lefty specialist, they aren’t spending $12.5 million per year on another bullpen piece. If that indeed is going to be his role, this is an excellent signing. If nothing else, he’s a pretty good hitter and could work with Joe Savery on being a decent hitting lefty pitcher.
December 13th, 2011 on 2:49 pm
I think Willis was on a one-year minor league contract with the Reds.
Eckersley was 32 when he was turned into a full-time reliever. He was really good as a starter, twice an All-Star and twice in the top ten in Cy Young voting over 12 seasons before spending another 12 as a reliever.
December 13th, 2011 on 4:34 pm
The other interesting part of all of this is that, well, let’s see, Francisco has been traded, the D Train has been signed, contracts have been tendered to the arbitration eligible, and as far as I know they have painted the clubhouse. And out there in la la land, Jimmy sits unsigned.
This whole contract thing is not for the faint of heart, is it?
December 13th, 2011 on 4:48 pm
Not so much. The good news for the Phils is that J-Roll is almost out of teams. The bad news for the Phils is that the world is almost out of SS. Everyone’s assuming he’s coming back (me too), but given the alternatives it’s going to be a pretty big problem if he doesn’t.
Jayson Stark suggests the Tigers might be interested in Rollins.
http://twitter.com/#!/jaysonst/status/146704805295947777
December 13th, 2011 on 5:29 pm
And sitting down in our minor league is a guy who is hoping that Jimmy signs with someone, ANYone, who does not weaar red pinstripes.
Freddy, someday we want to be able to cheer you lustily. Just not quite yet.
December 14th, 2011 on 9:36 am
You will find that the Phillies actually led the league in scoring from May 23rd on.
December 14th, 2011 on 1:04 pm
Yup. 5/23 to the end of May, the Phils played nine games and scored 51 runs or 5.67 runs per game. In that stretch they took three of four from the Reds, scoring 28 runs in the set and twice scoring ten runs in a game. After that they took two of three from the Mets, scoring 16 runs in that three-game set. They ended the month splitting the first two games of a three-game set with the Nats, scoring seven runs in those games.
After that, from the start of June to the end of the year, they scored 486 runs the rest of the way, which was fourth in the NL.
May 23 is important, of course, because it’s the day Chase Utley returned to the Phils.
I have trouble seeing Utley’s return as the turning point for the offense, although it’s impossible to deny they led the NL in runs scored after he came back. Mostly it’s hard for me just cause they were 11th in the league in runs scored in June, his first full month back.
Also, the nine-game surge at the end of May didn’t have a whole lot to do with Utley. At least not with what he did on the field. He hit just .222 from May 23 to the end of the month. The offensive success the Phils had in those nine games had a lot more to do with what Ibanez (300/318/700), Ruiz (393/485/536) and Howard (273/400/576) did than Utley’s production. Brown was crushing the ball as well. He started six of those games and played in all nine, hitting 379/424/621.
December 15th, 2011 on 12:37 pm
You’re right about the other players turning it on, but Utley did have an impact in a couple of ways:
1) The fuzzier one is whether having Utley in the lineup allows the batting order to be set up like it’s meant to, and in general has a beneficial effect on the other hitters.
2) The more concrete one is the impact of moving from a very bad hitter (Valdez) and one of the worst hitters (MiniMart), to Utley, who finished the season (despite a down year) as the 8th best hitting second baseman, and 3rd best in the NL.
December 15th, 2011 on 2:48 pm
I totally agree, especially on the second point.
I think we need to remember Orr as well as part of the pre-Utley problem, too. Utley, as you know, was back 5/23 and a full-time player in June. Through the end of June, the Phillies had played 82 games. Utley had started 31 of them at second, Valdez had started 31 at second, Orr had started 16 at second and Martinez four. Orr was even worse offensively than those other two guys while playing 2B for the Phils in 2011, hitting 213/280/240 in 82 plate appearances while playing 2B.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/play-index/split_stats_team.cgi?full=1¶ms=defp|as%202B|PHI|2011|bat|AB|
After the end of June, Utley started 69 of 80 games at second for the Phils.
I think the other thing that’s important to remember is that Utley was fantastic offensively in June, hitting 297/387/473 for the month and the Phils were still eleventh in the league in runs scored that month, so I think there are more moving pieces than just Utley coming back. As you suggest above, it seems likely that his return did have ripples to other positions. I do think that Utley taking at-bats away from miserable offensive players after he returned was one of the big factors in the second half surge for the offense, but not the only one and maybe not even the most important one (others include Ruiz and Rollins hitting way better in the second half, the emergence of Mayberry and the addition of Pence). Sometime soon I want to get up a post that looks at the offense position by position before and after the end of June.
December 14th, 2011 on 10:37 am
On the other hand, a full year of Freddy has to be an upgrade over a full year of Valdez and Martinez.
December 14th, 2011 on 10:43 am
Defensively, at least.
December 14th, 2011 on 11:48 am
I have heard good things about Freddy defensively, though I have never seeen him play. Does he have Valdez’ arm?
December 14th, 2011 on 11:53 am
BTW, is there any way to guess if there is really a “mystery team” out there or if this is a ploy? If there is a team, and it is the Tigers, is that a real threat? Jimmy will be expensive for anyone who signs him, especially if he gets the years he wants.
December 14th, 2011 on 12:33 pm
Not sure about his arm, but he definitely has a Freddy Galvis bat.
I don’t think we should assume Galvis would outperform Valdez offensively. Galvis has a career 246/292/321 line in the minors with 126 plate appearances above Double-A. Valdez has better numbers than that in the majors (just barely) — 243/290/330.
I don’t think that the Tigers are a real threat to sign Rollins. But I do not know for sure. I think Rollins will come back to the Phils. Soon.
December 14th, 2011 on 1:24 pm
The Rollins/Phillies dance has gone on for a long time. I hope no one got bruised in all of this. I think that if I am Jimmy, I am not having warm and fuzzy Santa Claus feelings about my agent right now. A little too much “King Albert” and not enough “J-Roll”.
Um, and Valdez is a little better than Galvis offensively? Now there is a cheery thought.
December 14th, 2011 on 1:27 pm
I actually think Valdez would be a lot better than Galvis offensively if they both got a lot of at-bats in 2012. I don’t think that’s going to happen, though.
I am going to be very surprised if Galvis gets 250 at-bats with the Phils this year and absolutely floored if he gets 250 at-bats with the Phils this year and not undeniably horrid with the bat.
December 14th, 2011 on 2:16 pm
Agreed on Galvis v. Valdez. As one who follows the minors closely (sometimes I think closer than the big club), I’ve been following Freddy for some time hoping that he would do something with the bat. 2011 was the first year that he had decent offensive numbers, and it was also the first year that he wasn’t one of the 2-3 youngest guys in his league. It seems like we’ve been following him forever, but he is only going to be 22 when the 2012 season starts.
In my mind, the important thing for him is to be getting everyday at bats in the minors to continue to learn that side of things. Minor league defensive numbers are notoriously unreliable, but everybody who has seen him play in person gushes over how smooth he looks in the field, so I don’t think there is much to worry about there if he were in Philadelphia from day one. The bat however doesn’t even seem acceptable for an 8-hole hitter, especially considering he just does not walk enough. I would love to see another year of progress with the bat (even if he just replicates last year’s numbers) in AAA with a possible September call-up before dropping him into the lineup every day. Brown was/is a far superior bat and we saw how much he struggled when asked to replace Werth. I can only imagine the pressure would be even greater to replace Rollins.
December 14th, 2011 on 2:42 pm
I don’t know, but I don’t think the Phillies really think there is any chance they would make Galvis an everyday player in 2012. It does raise the question of why they would suggest they were willing to do so. I think the answer there is that is is not to improve their negotiating position with Rollins — I think Rollins knows that he’s going to be way, way better than Freddy Galvis in 2012 and knows the Phillies know that as well. I think the answer might be they say they are willing to do so to help the fans be prepared in case there is some sort of disaster where they don’t get a proven major league SS before the start of 2012.
December 14th, 2011 on 2:59 pm
So, what in the world do we do if we do NOT sign Rollins? If Galvis is as bad offensively as the discussion here demonstrates he is, do they actually think they can survive that kind of offensive drop off? There really is no one available anymore besides these two guys (Rollins & Galvis), is there? If that is true, why am I seeing all ths stuff in print about Amaro being “in the driver’s seat”?
Greg, is there anyone else down on the farm?
December 14th, 2011 on 3:45 pm
I think the Phillies depth chart at SS right now goes Valdez followed by Martinez/Galvis. I think the Phils will sign Rollins. If they don’t, I think it’s easy for them to acquire a player that’s better than Martinez or Galvis. I would guess if they don’t sign Rollins they will sign some other player who can play short and is about as good as Valdez. I don’t really think playing Martinez/Galvis is a legitimate option for the Phils, so I’m not sure how much it matters whether they could handle the dropoff of starting him or not, but I think they could go to the playoffs with Galvis or Martinez or Valdez as their everyday SS although things would have to go pretty well and injury free at the other hitting positions.
Amaro is in the driver’s seat in the sense that there are a very limited number of teams who are thought to be looking for a starting SS other than the Phillies.
They also have Harold Garcia, Cesar Hernandez and Carlos Rivero on their 40-man roster currently. I don’t think any of those guys are in the SS picture.
December 14th, 2011 on 3:50 pm
If Jimmy does not sign, does anyone think that RAJ would look elsewhere to improve another position? (Read: sign someone to play left or third or somewhere who is offensively much better than what we have currently.)
December 14th, 2011 on 3:53 pm
I don’t think he has a lot of slots open on his team since adding Thome, Wigginton, Nix. I don’t know the answer to your question, but I would guess not. Again, I think Rollins will be back with the Phils. If he’s not, I think Edgar Renteria, Ryan Theriot and Cesar Izturis might be the kind of guys the Phils would be looking to bring in to help out at short. Let’s hope it doesn’t come to that.
December 14th, 2011 on 5:10 pm
Fingers crossed.
December 16th, 2011 on 8:48 am
I’m guessing that nothing gets done till after the new year. Seems kind of silly to me, but then what do I know.
December 16th, 2011 on 10:42 am
From a clip posted on FB, when asked if he would go out and get someone if Jimmy does not sign, RAJ replied, “Basically, Galvis is ready to go (play)”.
Ho Ho Ho.
December 16th, 2011 on 3:45 pm
Hopefully he meant that Galvis is ready to go out and give it his all as an IronPig. I’m rooting for him. Hitting .235 with a .305 on-base percentage and no power in the Venezuelan Winter league doesn’t really make it seem like Galvis is ready to go out and play everyday for the Phils. I’d be a little surprised if there are too many folks that work for the Phillies who think he is.
December 16th, 2011 on 4:11 pm
Yeah. Kind of made me wince when I heard him say it. I cannot believe HE believes it.
December 16th, 2011 on 7:59 pm
Cuddyer to rockies for 3 years.
December 17th, 2011 on 3:34 pm
J I M M Y. Three years, option for a fourth. I’m feeling good about this one.
December 17th, 2011 on 6:56 pm
There ya go Jimmy!
December 18th, 2011 on 5:28 pm
And RAJ didn’t break the bank doing it. The man seems to know What he’s doing.
December 19th, 2011 on 10:16 am
The Rollins contract really surprised me. He’s making less than Papelbon. Seems like I’d be irritated if I were Jimmy, but who knows.
To answer the (now moot) question on the other minor league shortstops…no, there isn’t anybody else. Eric mentioned the three other guys on the 40-man. Carlos Rivero has a lot of promise, but spent all of last year playing third while Galvis played short. He was a SS in the Indians system, but the Phillies are hoping to make a third baseman out of him. If he can learn to play the field (didn’t have a good 2011), and takes another step forward with the bat, he could be an improvement over Polanco in 2013. I have high hopes for him.
Cesar Hernandez is a player I had some hope for heading into 2011, but he struggled really bad in Clearwater. He is, at best, 3 years away from being a Wilson Valdez clone. And when I say at best, I mean he’d have to be pretty lucky to turn out to be that good. He’ll likely be one of the first guys jettisoned from the 40-man.
Harold Garcia had a very promising 2010 season and was off to a good start in 2011 before tearing his ACL in April and missing the rest of the season. Who knows what will happen when he comes back, but he’s likely too old to be considered a “prospect” any more.
They did draft three very, very promising middle infielders in the 2011 draft, but all three of them just graduated from high school this past summer. I wouldn’t count on seeing them in the bigs for at least 3 years if everything goes really well.
Long story short…no there is nobody else on the farm.
December 19th, 2011 on 2:11 pm
I think the good news on the SS front is that the Phils would have little trouble picking up someone better than any of their minor league options were Rollins to go down. I don’t think any of the three guys Greg mentioned above who are currently on the 40-man roster are ever going to help the Phils. Galvis might, but it seems like he’s got some offensive developing to do.
I think the Rollins deal definitely could have been worse for the Phils. $33 million over the next three years isn’t exactly free, though, especially for a guy who has on-based .316 over the last three seasons. In 2009, Rollins was atrocious, on-basing .296. 2010 he walked a lot more, but his power disappeared. It seems like offensively the best we can hope for with Rollins is a repeat of his 2011 campaign, which was pretty good but far from great.
December 19th, 2011 on 3:53 pm
Greg, it’s nice to have your info around, even of what you are telling us is not real encouraging. I guess this is the result of the trades we have made. How is it that you are focused on the minors and have access to so much info from there? I can’t find much around me here in Philly.
My impression is that out low minors are very promising but that our high minors are pretty well picked over because of teh trades we have made. Except for Brown, though I am not a fan of his.
SO… now, the next question is, do we think that RAJ is done adding guys to this team?
December 20th, 2011 on 9:56 am
DaMannse – I get my minor league info from http://www.phuturephillies.com (if Eric will excuse me for pushing another blog). It is by far the best team specific minor league site in all of baseball, and we’re lucky that they focus on the Phils.
The low minors are pretty well stacked for this team, and the high minors have some possibly useful players. Reading will be very fun to follow this year because all of the “Baby Aces” will be there with the exception of the lefty Biddle. In all, I think the system has more depth than it has in years in spite of all of the trades, but they don’t have many “super star” potential type guys if that makes any sense. There are still a lot of guys in the system to be excited about.
As far as your question about adding guys, *I* think we’ve seen the last major move we’ll see before the season starts. There will be some minor moves and some ST invites and stuff, but I think we can pretty much see what this team is going to look like in the start of 2012. I say this full well knowing that if there is an obvious weakness on this team, it will be addressed by July 31st.
December 20th, 2011 on 11:04 am
Ed Wade’s back. Wonder if he can play third.
December 20th, 2011 on 12:48 pm
Thanks, Greg. Appreciate the info.
My Christmas list for Santa was pretty short, but it did include a 3rd baseman with a bat and ribbies. A guy can hope, anyway. Sigh.
December 20th, 2011 on 1:59 pm
Between Lidge, Oswalt and Pence it was kinda like Wade never left. At least he’ll have some friendly faces around, including Thome.
I think there’s a chance that Wigginton can get enough time at 3B to make the Phils better at that position in 2012. Will have to wait and see.
December 20th, 2011 on 2:02 pm
There’s always deadline deals as well. We might be able to pry someone like Young loose in July if the Rangers are taking back-to-back WS losses well.
December 20th, 2011 on 2:03 pm
And by “are”, I mean “aren’t”.
December 20th, 2011 on 6:53 pm
My Santa request tried to reach beyond “a chance that Wigginton can get enough time at 3B to make the Phils better at that position”. LOL
December 21st, 2011 on 2:39 pm
Well…remember all of those nice things I said before about Carlos Rivero? Nevermind. The Phillies released him and he was claimed by the Nationals today.
December 21st, 2011 on 3:33 pm
Yup. I saw that. Would not even have known the name without your post of the other day.
December 21st, 2011 on 5:01 pm
MLB saying that the Phillies added infielder Hector Luna (age 31) and outfielder Luis Montanez (age 30) to their minor leagues and invited them to spring training.
Also that the Nats are trying really hard to land Gio Gonzalez from the As. And that if they do nto get him, they will look at Roy Oswalt, who has dropped his demands from a 3 year deal to being willing to sign for 1 year.
December 22nd, 2011 on 9:35 am
I think Luna can hit better than Galvis/Martinez. Don’t think he can play SS, though — I think he’s appeared there once in the minors since then end of 2008.
Montanez was the third pick in the 2000 draft. The Cubs took him 12 picks before the Phils took Utley. He’s old now, too, but has hit well in the minors despite not-so-good results in the majors.
I wouldn’t hold your breath on either of those guys.
I saw the news about Oswalt willing to take a one-year deal, too. Kind of a surprise to me, cause he’s not that old at just 34.
Nats are going to need to add more than Gio Gonzalez before I start to worry.
December 22nd, 2011 on 10:32 am
I have to admit that I am a little anxious about the Phillies. With Howard gone – and I think he will be gone far longer than anyone is saying out loud, much less be back and actually effective – I think that RAJ’s estimation of his line up is extraordinarily optimistic. I am trying to see where the runs are going to come from to make up for the runs Ibanez and Howard produced. Howard is an RBI machine. Wigginton is a nice bench guy, but he is no Ryan Howard.
“If everyone stays healthy” feels pretty squishy, given the last two years. Utley’s power days may be behind him. Pence should help, being here the whole year, but I just feel edgy about that being enough. And I wish third or left field had been a place where RAJ had gone for a serious bat. I continue to be bummed that Ramirez went elsewhere. Really bummed.
December 22nd, 2011 on 10:47 am
Whole year of Pence (we hope). Whole year of Utley (we hope). Ibanez was atrocious last year. I think left field gets better in 2012.
Mayberry isn’t going to produce as his 2011 levels in 2012. If he did, though, and got the same 575 plate appearances that Ibanez got in 2011, he would put up 29 homers and 95 RBI.
No idea how much time Howard is going to miss. If Thome can really play 1B, he can be a huge help while Howard is out. Thome was a good offensive player last year and a great offensive player in 2010. He’s going to get old sometime, let’s hope it’s not yet.
I agree the Phils aren’t in real good shape to deal with major injuries if they occur.
December 22nd, 2011 on 2:15 pm
Thome. Geez. I had forgotten Big Jim. He’s another one of those “if” guys, but IF he can play he would sure help.
December 22nd, 2011 on 2:19 pm
Mayberry really is a wild card, then, isn’t he. Another “if”, but IF he can do this year what he did last, we would sure do well with 95 ribbies.
Man, I sure wish we had someone who has been there and done that, though.
December 22nd, 2011 on 2:39 pm
I really don’t know about Thome at 1B. If he can play first and still hit like Jim Thome, even if it’s only against righties, he can help the Phils a ton while Howard is out. 261/379/523 over the last three years. That’s good. Howard 270/353/524 over the last three years.
I think Mayberry will prove to be not quite as good as he was last year. If he’s really as good as he was last year, he’s great. I know you hate him, but Brown has monster upside. Not someone you want to count on in 2012, but he could surprise a lot of people I think.
December 22nd, 2011 on 3:49 pm
I cannot tell you how much I want to eat crow about Brown. Please, please, be a monster. I would rather me eat crow than he be a turkey.
December 22nd, 2011 on 9:48 pm
Nats get gio gonzalez
December 23rd, 2011 on 5:42 pm
Guys, I am seeing some stuff now about the Phillies being interested in David Wright. I have no way to measure how seriously to take this. It would require a trade; I wonder who we have to trade for that level player that would not absolutely kill us to lose.
December 27th, 2011 on 1:58 pm
Should be taken not seriously. It’s a nice thought, though.
http://www.metsblog.com/2011/12/24/rt-jonheymancbs-folks-can-stop-speculating-about-the-mets-trading-david-wright-to-the-phillies/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+metsblogfeed+%28MetsBlog.com%29